UPPER YARRA STAR MAIL
Home » Opinion » An exquisite gothic mystery

An exquisite gothic mystery



The Silence Factory, by British author Bridget Collins, has a setting very much like Victorian Britain.

The story begins with the writings of Sophia in 1820, who accompanies her husband James Ashmore-Percy to a remote Greek island to search for rare biological specimens.

History tells us that the Victorians were obsessed with science and progress, confident that their exploration and growing knowledge of the natural world could help improve society in the

same way as they were advancing technology.

It is this confidence – or the arrogance that men are entitled to all of nature’s offerings – that casts a terrifying shadow over Sophia’s life.

Decades later, audiologist Henry Latimer is sent to the home of industrialist Sir Edward Ashmore-Percy to help cure the man’s daughter of her deafness.

Here, Henry’s encounter with Philomel and her governess Miss Fielding plays a crucial role in his journey of self-discovery.

As explained by Miss Fielding: “[Philomel’s] father is determined that she should learn to speak aloud, so that she can participate in society. She cannot be limited to conversations with other people who can sign. Better that she should say a few broken words to the people who matter, than express herself perfectly to those who do not. True speech is what distinguishes us from animals, is it not?”

These words reflect the commonsense of the time, and may cause some distress to readers today who are more informed about the aspirations and strengths of people with disabilities.

But the author’s illustration of Philomel is empathetic and delightful, capturing the beauty and fearlessness of a young girl full of curiosity and energy.

The portrayal of Miss Fielding as a courageous woman full of love and compassion is also endearing.

Meanwhile, as Henry is drawn deeper into Sir Edward’s world, he finds himself obsessed with the fascinating nature of the man’s business – spinning silk with a rare and magical breed of spiders.

The extraordinary silk shields sound, offering respite from the everyday noise in one’s surroundings – “the screech of traffic and the cries of street vendors, or the endless rumble of machinery… Not to mention the relentless background groan of the city, monstrous and unending.”

The result is absolute tranquility and soothing calmness.

In Henry’s words: “Silence is not only silence, sir, it is attention – it is sanity. It is sleep for infants, medicine for invalids, rest for the working man – it is money for the man who must think or starve. We build walls to shelter our bodies from the world, but we leave our minds open to assault on every side.”

Silence is indeed golden, but, as Henry soon finds out, it comes with a price, both personal and collective.

The Silence Factory is an intriguing book, its writing stunningly exquisite, its depiction of the mysterious spiders creepy yet memorising, and its detailed examination of the dark and insatiable greed behind the industrialised capital world then – and now – is both captivating and alarming.

Highly recommended.

Digital Editions


More News

  • Big wins for Warby bowls

    Big wins for Warby bowls

    The Warburton Bowls Club recorded wonderful results on the weekend with both Pennant sides winning comfortably in vital games leading up to the finals. The Burras top side played third…

  • Outpouring of community support leaves woman thankful

    Outpouring of community support leaves woman thankful

    When Mena Buckley’s beloved greyhound, Tassie, crawled off the couch and collapsed on the floor, she knew it was time for her dog to go. She called her NDIS worker…

  • Justice of Peace appointments with Cr Child available

    Justice of Peace appointments with Cr Child available

    Yarra Ranges Council O’Shannassy Ward councillor Jim Child is offering Justice of the Peace services on Monday 2 February. Appointments can be made by calling 9294 6106 or dropping in…

  • ‘Incredibly grateful’: Community Bank donates $40,000 to local CFAs

    ‘Incredibly grateful’: Community Bank donates $40,000 to local CFAs

    The Community Bank Wandin-Seville donated crucial funding to four local CFA brigades on Monday 26 January. The $40,000 boost was presented at the Rotary Club of Wandin’s Family Fun Day…

  • Bushfire preparedness

    Bushfire preparedness

    Our community knows the unforgiving and unpredictable nature of bushfires all too well. Living in the bushfire prone Yarra Ranges and neighbouring the dense bushland of Murrindindi and Baw Baw…

  • A sequel even better than the first

    A sequel even better than the first

    28 Years Later: The Bone Temple Starring Alfie Williams, Ralph Fiennes and Jack O’Connell MA15+ 4.5/5 Directed by Nia DaCosta, 28 Years Later: The Bone Temple is an even better…

  • Home insurance explained

    Home insurance explained

    Cartoonist Danny Zemp depicts the “fat cats” profiting from insurance premiums for areas with a high natural disaster risk, such as the Yarra Ranges.

  • Regarding AI generated content – Part One

    Regarding AI generated content – Part One

    As a writer, translator, reader and reviewer, I am against the use of AI-generated content in any literary work. But this is a complex issue. Therefore, in this article, I…

  • Murder mystery marathon

    Murder mystery marathon

    Lilydale Athenaeum Theatre The Games Afoot Or Homes for the Holidays us a farce murder mystery. A “Who Dunnit” set in 1936 where the famous Broadway star William Gillette invites…

  • What constitutes leadership?

    What constitutes leadership?

    As we lean into the heat of summer with the dread that it brings in places prone to fires and health risks to the vulnerable, it’s also that time of…